Overview
What's Included
- Architecture comparison
- Use case recommendations
- Code examples for both platforms
- Performance and scalability analysis
- Developer experience differences
- Production deployment considerations
- Migration strategies
Step-by-Step Guide
1
Core Philosophy
Understanding the fundamental differences in design.
# AIRFLOW: DAG-based, schedule-driven
# - Workflows defined as Directed Acyclic Graphs
# - Tasks are independent units
# - Schedule-first thinking (cron-like)
# - Best for: ETL, data pipelines, batch jobs
# TEMPORAL: Code-first, event-driven
# - Workflows are regular code (Python, Go, Java)
# - Activities are function calls
# - Event-driven with durable execution
# - Best for: Microservices, long-running processes
# Key Difference:
# Airflow: "Run this DAG at 2am daily"
# Temporal: "Execute this workflow when event X occurs"
2
Code Comparison
How the same workflow looks in each platform.
# AIRFLOW: ETL Pipeline
from airflow import DAG
from airflow.operators.python import PythonOperator
from datetime import datetime
def extract(): pass
def transform(): pass
def load(): pass
with DAG('etl_pipeline', start_date=datetime(2024,1,1),
schedule='@daily') as dag:
t1 = PythonOperator(task_id='extract', python_callable=extract)
t2 = PythonOperator(task_id='transform', python_callable=transform)
t3 = PythonOperator(task_id='load', python_callable=load)
t1 >> t2 >> t3
# TEMPORAL: Order Processing
from temporalio import workflow, activity
from datetime import timedelta
@activity.defn
async def charge_payment(order_id: str) -> bool:
# Payment logic
return True
@activity.defn
async def ship_order(order_id: str) -> str:
# Shipping logic
return "shipped"
@workflow.defn
class OrderWorkflow:
@workflow.run
async def run(self, order_id: str):
paid = await workflow.execute_activity(
charge_payment, order_id,
start_to_close_timeout=timedelta(minutes=5))
if paid:
return await workflow.execute_activity(
ship_order, order_id,
start_to_close_timeout=timedelta(minutes=10))
3
Failure Handling
How each platform handles failures and retries.
# AIRFLOW: Task-level retries
PythonOperator(
task_id='my_task',
python_callable=my_function,
retries=3,
retry_delay=timedelta(minutes=5),
retry_exponential_backoff=True
)
# If task fails, entire DAG run may fail
# Manual intervention often needed
# State stored in metadata database
# TEMPORAL: Durable execution with automatic retries
@activity.defn
async def risky_operation():
# If this crashes, Temporal automatically retries
# Workflow state is preserved
# Can resume from exact point of failure
pass
# Temporal guarantees:
# - Workflow will complete (eventually)
# - No duplicate execution
# - Automatic retry with backoff
# - Full execution history preserved
4
When to Choose Each
Practical recommendations for different scenarios.
# Choose AIRFLOW When:
# - Building data pipelines (ETL/ELT)
# - Scheduled batch processing
# - Team is data engineering focused
# - You need extensive operator ecosystem
# - Visualizing DAG dependencies matters
# Choose TEMPORAL When:
# - Building microservice orchestration
# - Long-running business processes
# - You need exactly-once execution
# - Complex retry/compensation logic
# - Team is software engineering focused
# Use BOTH When:
# - Airflow for data pipelines
# - Temporal for application workflows
# - They solve different problems well
# FlowOps offers both on AWS Marketplace:
# - Pre-configured for production
# - 24/7 support included
Comparison
| Aspect | Apache Airflow | Temporal |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Use | Data pipelines | Application workflows |
| Paradigm | DAG-based | Code-first |
| Scheduling | Built-in (cron) | External/event-driven |
| State Management | Database | Event sourcing |
| Failure Recovery | Task retry | Durable execution |
| Learning Curve | Moderate | Steeper |
| UI | Excellent | Good |
| Ecosystem | Huge (1000+ operators) | Growing |
Use Cases
- ETL/ELT data pipelines (Airflow)
- ML model training workflows (Airflow)
- Order processing workflows (Temporal)
- Payment and subscription handling (Temporal)
- DevOps automation (Both)
- Report generation (Airflow)
Pricing
Our AMIs are available on AWS Marketplace with simple hourly pricing:
- Software: $0.10-0.15/hour (varies by product)
- EC2: Standard AWS pricing for your chosen instance
- Support: 24/7 included with guaranteed 24-hour response
Need Help?
Our UK-based support team is here to help you get the most out of your deployment. Email us at support@flowopsconsulting.co.uk for any questions.
Comments