Overview
What's Included
- True cost comparison with real numbers
- Performance benchmark results
- Operational overhead analysis
- Feature comparison table
- Decision framework
- Migration considerations
- Production recommendations
Step-by-Step Guide
1
Cost Comparison
Real monthly costs for equivalent configurations.
# Configuration: db.r5.xlarge equivalent
# 4 vCPUs, 32GB RAM, 500GB gp3 storage, Multi-AZ
# AWS RDS PostgreSQL:
# Instance: $876/month (Multi-AZ)
# Storage: $65/month (500GB gp3)
# Backups: $25/month (100GB)
# Total RDS: ~$966/month
# Self-Hosted EC2:
# 2x r5.xlarge: $364/month (Multi-AZ via replication)
# 2x 500GB gp3: $100/month
# FlowOps AMI: $73/month ($0.10/hr)
# Total EC2: ~$537/month
# Savings: $429/month = $5,148/year (44% less)
# Note: Self-hosted requires more operational expertise
# RDS handles backups, patching, failover automatically
2
Performance Analysis
Benchmark results for common workloads.
# Benchmark: pgbench, 100 concurrent connections
# Same instance type: r5.xlarge
# Transactions Per Second (TPS):
# Self-hosted EC2: 12,500 TPS
# RDS: 11,200 TPS
# Winner: EC2 (~11% faster)
# Reason: RDS has overhead for managed features
# - Automated backups during operation
# - Enhanced monitoring
# - Multi-AZ synchronous replication
# Query Latency (p99):
# Self-hosted: 2.1ms
# RDS: 2.4ms
# IOPS (gp3 baseline 3000):
# Both: Similar when properly configured
# Note: RDS I/O depends on instance class
3
Operational Comparison
What you manage vs what AWS manages.
# RDS Handles Automatically:
# - OS patching and updates
# - PostgreSQL minor version upgrades
# - Automated daily backups
# - Point-in-time recovery
# - Multi-AZ failover (<60 seconds)
# - Storage auto-scaling
# - Performance Insights
# - CloudWatch integration
# Self-Hosted You Handle:
# - OS security patches
# - PostgreSQL upgrades
# - Backup scripts and testing
# - Replication setup (Patroni/repmgr)
# - Failover configuration
# - Monitoring setup
# - Connection pooling (PgBouncer)
# FlowOps AMI Includes:
# - Pre-configured PostgreSQL
# - pgAdmin web interface
# - Backup scripts to S3
# - Prometheus metrics
# - 24/7 support
4
Decision Framework
When to choose each option.
# Choose RDS When:
# - You have no dedicated DBA
# - Compliance requires managed services
# - You need automated Multi-AZ failover
# - Budget is flexible, time is not
# - You value simplicity over control
# Choose Self-Hosted When:
# - Cost optimization is critical (40%+ savings)
# - You need specific PostgreSQL extensions
# - You require maximum performance
# - You have database expertise in-house
# - You need OS-level access
# Hybrid Approach:
# - Production: RDS for reliability
# - Development/Staging: Self-hosted for cost savings
# - Analytics: Self-hosted for heavy workloads
Comparison
| Aspect | Self-Hosted EC2 | AWS RDS |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Cost | ~$537 | ~$966 |
| Performance | Better | Good |
| Operational Load | Higher | Minimal |
| Failover | Manual/Patroni | Automatic |
| Backups | You configure | Automatic |
| Extensions | Any | Limited list |
| OS Access | Full | None |
Use Cases
- Web application databases
- SaaS multi-tenant databases
- Analytics and data warehousing
- Microservices backends
- Legacy application migration
- Development environments
Pricing
Our AMIs are available on AWS Marketplace with simple hourly pricing:
- Software: $0.10-0.15/hour (varies by product)
- EC2: Standard AWS pricing for your chosen instance
- Support: 24/7 included with guaranteed 24-hour response
Need Help?
Our UK-based support team is here to help you get the most out of your deployment. Email us at support@flowopsconsulting.co.uk for any questions.
Comments