Home
Comparison

Self-Hosted PostgreSQL vs AWS RDS: The Real Cost Analysis

AWS RDS makes PostgreSQL easy, but is it worth the premium? This analysis breaks down the real costs, hidden trade-offs, and performance differences between self-hosted PostgreSQL on EC2 and fully-managed RDS.

10 min read FlowOps Consulting

What's Included

  • True cost comparison with real numbers
  • Performance benchmark results
  • Operational overhead analysis
  • Feature comparison table
  • Decision framework
  • Migration considerations
  • Production recommendations

Step-by-Step Guide

1

Cost Comparison

Real monthly costs for equivalent configurations.

# Configuration: db.r5.xlarge equivalent # 4 vCPUs, 32GB RAM, 500GB gp3 storage, Multi-AZ # AWS RDS PostgreSQL: # Instance: $876/month (Multi-AZ) # Storage: $65/month (500GB gp3) # Backups: $25/month (100GB) # Total RDS: ~$966/month # Self-Hosted EC2: # 2x r5.xlarge: $364/month (Multi-AZ via replication) # 2x 500GB gp3: $100/month # FlowOps AMI: $73/month ($0.10/hr) # Total EC2: ~$537/month # Savings: $429/month = $5,148/year (44% less) # Note: Self-hosted requires more operational expertise # RDS handles backups, patching, failover automatically
2

Performance Analysis

Benchmark results for common workloads.

# Benchmark: pgbench, 100 concurrent connections # Same instance type: r5.xlarge # Transactions Per Second (TPS): # Self-hosted EC2: 12,500 TPS # RDS: 11,200 TPS # Winner: EC2 (~11% faster) # Reason: RDS has overhead for managed features # - Automated backups during operation # - Enhanced monitoring # - Multi-AZ synchronous replication # Query Latency (p99): # Self-hosted: 2.1ms # RDS: 2.4ms # IOPS (gp3 baseline 3000): # Both: Similar when properly configured # Note: RDS I/O depends on instance class
3

Operational Comparison

What you manage vs what AWS manages.

# RDS Handles Automatically: # - OS patching and updates # - PostgreSQL minor version upgrades # - Automated daily backups # - Point-in-time recovery # - Multi-AZ failover (<60 seconds) # - Storage auto-scaling # - Performance Insights # - CloudWatch integration # Self-Hosted You Handle: # - OS security patches # - PostgreSQL upgrades # - Backup scripts and testing # - Replication setup (Patroni/repmgr) # - Failover configuration # - Monitoring setup # - Connection pooling (PgBouncer) # FlowOps AMI Includes: # - Pre-configured PostgreSQL # - pgAdmin web interface # - Backup scripts to S3 # - Prometheus metrics # - 24/7 support
4

Decision Framework

When to choose each option.

# Choose RDS When: # - You have no dedicated DBA # - Compliance requires managed services # - You need automated Multi-AZ failover # - Budget is flexible, time is not # - You value simplicity over control # Choose Self-Hosted When: # - Cost optimization is critical (40%+ savings) # - You need specific PostgreSQL extensions # - You require maximum performance # - You have database expertise in-house # - You need OS-level access # Hybrid Approach: # - Production: RDS for reliability # - Development/Staging: Self-hosted for cost savings # - Analytics: Self-hosted for heavy workloads

Comparison

AspectSelf-Hosted EC2AWS RDS
Monthly Cost~$537~$966
PerformanceBetterGood
Operational LoadHigherMinimal
FailoverManual/PatroniAutomatic
BackupsYou configureAutomatic
ExtensionsAnyLimited list
OS AccessFullNone

Use Cases

  • Web application databases
  • SaaS multi-tenant databases
  • Analytics and data warehousing
  • Microservices backends
  • Legacy application migration
  • Development environments

Pricing

Our AMIs are available on AWS Marketplace with simple hourly pricing:

Need Help?

Our UK-based support team is here to help you get the most out of your deployment. Email us at support@flowopsconsulting.co.uk for any questions.

Ready to Get Started?

Deploy in 5 minutes on AWS Marketplace

View on AWS Marketplace

Comments